4-Part Chorale for Matthew Chapter 27

1. Trial and Choice

This movement could focus on the trial of Jesus before Pilate, juxtaposed with the crowd demanding the release of Barabbas. The music here could reflect the tension and turmoil of the scene, with dissonant harmonies and a call-and-response structure between the parts, illustrating the dialogue between Pilate, Jesus, and the crowd.

2. Mockery and Crucifixion

This section would depict the soldiers mocking Jesus, crowning Him with thorns, and leading Him away to be crucified. The music could be somber and melancholic, with a slower tempo and minor keys dominating. The use of chromaticism could reflect the pain and sorrow of the events, with a gradual build-up leading to the crucifixion.

3. Death of Jesus

At this poignant moment, the music could shift to a more subdued and introspective tone, reflecting the moment of Jesus' death. A single melody line could be passed between the voices, symbolizing Jesus' final words, with the other voices providing a soft, sustained harmony that underscores the gravity and solemnity of the moment.

4. Burial and Guard

The final movement could start with a more somber and reflective tone, depicting the burial of Jesus. The music could then shift to a more tense and uncertain mood as the guards are set at the tomb, reflecting the disciples' fear and the anticipation of what is to come. The ending could be left open-ended, with a lingering dissonance or unresolved harmony, pointing towards the resurrection narrative in the next chapter.